Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nick's avatar

As a 19 year old who is currently trying to figure out a direction for my life, this hit hard. Amazing writing, thank you.

Expand full comment
Desert Surfer's avatar

I was 14 years old when legends of the fall came out, and it has been my all-time favorite film. Something about it, even at that young age resonated with me, most likely due to the thirst for adventure. I recommend reading the novel as well, it is epic.

At 18, I set out on my own adventure, although not quite like what Tristan did, though I wish I had, and I still regret not having done so to the extent that I wanted. But I saw enough and experienced enough to grow into a proper man and shed the wolf cloak (somewhat). I don't know if it's possible (or feasible) for a man to truly ever be rid of the wolf (or bear) that's inside of him.

In comparing fictional characters however, at the suggestion of my wife, I reluctantly watched the series Outlanders with her which, to my surprise has actually turned out to be quite good. The main character, James Fraser starts out similarly to Tristan, going on many extreme adventures, but unlike Tristan always come back to his wife, fights for her honor, as well as his family's and community.

When I asked my wife which man she preferred, of course, without hesitation, she chose James Fraser. At 44 years of age today, it's easy to understand why, and having gone through what I have in life, and now being fortunate enough to have an amazing wife and family, I would choose to be him over Tristan as well.

Although Tristan got what he ultimately longed for "a good death," his life as a whole, although adventurous, was tragic, because of the choices he made and those that he lost.

Granted, we will all lose loved ones in our lifetime, and will experience many tragedies. But, as you alluded to in your fantastic essay...try to live a life of adventure, without alienating and/or hurting the ones you love, so that you can hopefully return to the world, be surrounded by those you love, and live a good life. And hopefully still one day, receive "a good death."

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts